Order Delicious Pepperoni Pizza & More in
New Castle, PA
Four Star Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs proudly serves the best pizza, subs, and wings in New Castle, PA. Whether you’re craving pepperoni pizza, Italian subs, or hot wings, you can count on us for quality flavors, fast delivery, and affordable prices. View our menu below, then call us today to place your order!
1506 Old Butler Rd
New Castle, PA 16101
(724) 656-9222- Mon - Thu
- -
- Fri - Sat
- -
- Sunday
- Closed
WE DELIVER!
Local Motel Delivery Available
Limited Delivery Area
*Prices Subject to Change
Most subs come topped with provolone cheese and are topped with lettuce, tomato, & Onion. Mayo or Italian Dressing on the side
ITALIAN | HAM | TURKEY | MEATBALL | PEPPERONI | VEGGIE - $7.99
STEAK | SAUSAGE | CHICKEN | BLT | BBQ CHICKEN | BUFFALO CHICKEN | CHICKEN PARMESAN - $9.00
Extra Meat - $2.49
Extra Cheese - $1.05
Six Inch Available - $5.00+tax
Choice of Dressing: Italian, French, Ranch, Balsamic
GARDEN
Small - $4.99
Large - $5.99
CHEF
Small - $5.99
Large - $7.99
CHICKEN
Small - $6.99
Large - $8.99
STEAK
Small - $6.99
Large - $8.99
EXTRA DRESSING - $0.85
CHEESE
7" - $4.49
12" - $8.99
16" - $12.99
ADDITIONAL TOPPINGS
7" - $0.75
12" - $1.50
16" - $1.95
Specialty
Pizza
DELUXE
Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, & Green Peppers
7" - $6.49
12" - $12.99
16" - $16.99
VEGGIE
Broccoli, Cauliflower, Special Sauces, & Two Cheeses
7" - $6.49
12" - $12.99
16" - $16.99
POOR MAN'S (WHITE)
Cheese, Banana Peppers, Oil, Garlic, & Tomatoes
7" - $6.49
12" - $12.99
16" - $16.99
BRIER HILL
Banana Peppers, Parmesan, Sauce
7" - $6.49
12" - $12.99
16" - $16.99
BACON TRIPLE CHEESE
7" - $6.49
12" - $12.99
16" - $16.99
CHICKEN, BACON, RANCH, & TWO CHEESES
7" - $6.49
12" - $12.99
16" - $16.99
BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA
7" - $6.49
12" - $12.99
16" - $16.99
BUFFALO CHICKEN PIZZA
7" - $6.49
12" - $12.99
16" - $16.99
MEAT LOVERS PIZZA
7" - $6.49
12" - $12.99
16" - $16.99
PHILLY STEAK
Steak, Onion, Green Pepper, Cheese, & Special Sauce
7" - $6.49
12" - $12.99
16" - $16.99
ORIGINAL CHILI DOG
Chili, Hot Dogs, Onions, Cheese Blend
7" - $6.49
12" - $12.99
16" - $16.99
PHILLY STEAK STROMBOLI
Includes Cheese, Onions, Green Peppers - $8.99
MEATBALL STROMBOLI
Includes Sauce & Cheese - $8.99
DELUXE STROMBOLI
Includes Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Banana Peppers, & Cheese - $8.99
PIZZA STROMBOLI
Pepperoni, Cheese - $8.99
HAM & CHEESE - $8.99
ITALIAN STROMBOLI
Salami, Capicola Ham, Pepperoni, Onions & Banana Peppers - $8.99
Each includes sauce.
SAUSAGE & CHEESE - $6.49
HAM & CHEESE - $6.49
PEPPERONI & CHEESE - $6.49
MEATBALL & CHEESE - $6.49
STEAK & CHEESE - $6.49
Baked to Perfection
SINGLE PAK (10-12) - $13.99
FAMILY PAK (20-24) - $26.99
PARTY PAK (42-48) - $51.99
Sauces:
Hot, Mild, Barbeque, Ranch, Garlic, Garlic Parm, or Any Combo
CHEESE STIXX
A Great Tasting Blend of Four Star Fresh Dough, Real Mozzarella Cheese, & Pizza Sauce - $5.99
BREAD STIXX
Delicious Fresh Baked; Includes Sauce - $5.49
CINNA STIXX
with icing - $5.49
NEW! WARM CHOC CHIP COOKIE
8 inch pan - $6.99
FRENCH FRIES - $3.49
ADD CHILI $1.49
ADD CHEESE $1.05
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mt Dew, Root Beer, Orange Crush, Starry
20 OZ. BOTTLE - $2.49
2-LITER BOTTLE - $3.29
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mt Dew, Root Beer, Starry, Orange Crush
20 OZ. BOTTLE - $2.49
2-LITER BOTTLE - $3.25
Each includes sauce.
SAUSAGE & CHEESE - $6.49
HAM & CHEESE - $6.49
PEPPERONI & CHEESE - $6.49
MEATBALL & CHEESE - $6.49
STEAK & CHEESE - $6.49
1506 Old Butler Rd | New Castle, PA 16101
(724) 656-9222- Sunday
- Closed
- Mon - Thu
- -
- Fri - Sat
- -
WE DELIVER!
Four Star Pizza is proud to be locally owned and managed to give you the best customer service in town. Our staff takes pride in serving our community with the highest quality products and the friendliest delivery service possible. Four Star Pizza is quickly becoming the Big Taste in small towns!
Baked to Perfection
SINGLE PAK (10-12) - $12.99
FAMILY PAK (20-24) - $24.99
PARTY PAK (42-48) - $47.99
Sauces:
Hot, Mild, Barbeque, Ranch, Garlic, Garlic Parm, or Any Combo
Baked to Perfection
SINGLE PAK (10-12) - $12.99
FAMILY PAK (20-24) - $24.99
PARTY PAK (42-48) - $47.99
Sauces:
Hot, Mild, Barbeque, Ranch, Garlic, Garlic Parm, or Any Combo
CHEESE STIXX
A Great Tasting Blend of Four Star Fresh Dough, Real Mozzarella Cheese, & Pizza Sauce - $5.99
BREAD STIXX
Delicious Fresh Baked; Includes Sauce - $5.49
CINNA STIXX
with icing - $5.49
HOT CHOCOLATE CHIP PIZZA COOKIE - $6.99
FRENCH FRIES - $3.99
ADD CHILI $1.49
ADD CHEESE $0.99
CHEESE STIXX
A Great Tasting Blend of Four Star Fresh Dough, Real Mozzarella Cheese, & Pizza Sauce - $5.99
BREAD STIXX
Delicious Fresh Baked; Includes Sauce - $5.49
CINNA STIXX
with icing - $5.49
HOT CHOCOLATE CHIP PIZZA COOKIE - $6.99
FRENCH FRIES - $3.99
ADD CHILI $1.49
ADD CHEESE $0.99
Order Today for Quick Pizza Delivery
When you’re craving pizza and want it fast, call Four Star Pizza & Fresh Baked Subs in New Castle, PA. We offer quick pizza delivery and convenient carryout options. Call our pizza shop today to place your order!